Posted by
Bert Chapman on Thursday, July 08, 2010 7:43:41 PM
I was fortunate to live near the Gulf of Mexico from late 1989-1994. Although I lived in southeast Texas, I got to see part of the Louisiana section of the coast too. It is truly one of creation's treasures with its warm weather and the vast variety of land and marine ecosystems along its shores. It's also an area that God decided to endow with extensive petroleum reserves. States that are located on the Gulf Coast, particularly Louisiana, have had a Faustian bargain since the development of the modern petroleum industry. On one hand, they've been able to attract plenty of tourists to their shores and receive large amounts of money from these oil and natural gas reserves. On the other hand, they have been subject to energy price volatility and to the environmental damage that can be caused by oil spills and and which has also been caused by the depletion of wetlands due to oil drilling and some other human activities.
There is risk inherent in offshore oil drilling and no one should try to tell us otherwise. British Petroleum has its strengths and weaknesses like any other petroleum company. Other oil companies and their fellow private sector contractors have failed to meet safety regulations. The federal government, including Congress, has failed to effectively enforce federal laws and regulations on oil drilling. Although agencies such as the Minerals Management Service, Interior Dept. Office of Inspector General and Government Accountability Office have prepared numerous congressionally mandated and publicly accessible reports on offshore oil drilling program performance, it's highly doubtful grandstanding members of Congress have ever looked at those reports. You would think annual agency budget requests would be a good time for relevant congressional oversight committees to look at these reports and check and see if the already extensive corpus of federal laws and regulations on offshore drilling are working or need revising and if these agencies were doing their jobs properly!
Unfortunately, most members of these committees, such as Rep. Henry Waxman, the unctuous ambulance chasing chair of the House Energy & Commerce Committee, are most interested in strutting like peacocks having fits of righteous indignation at BP then actually trying to solve this problem. You would like to think that petroleum company representatives, the Obama Administration, and Congress would be historically literate and familiar with the lessons learned and produced in the documentary record about the 1969 Santa Barbara, CA and 1989 Alaskan Exxon Valdez spills. Instead, they run around like decapitated chickens shouting about the need to kick someone's posterior.
While we need to forcefully emphasize the need for BP and the government to stop the oil spill, clean up the mess as much as possible, and financially sustain Gulf Coast residents whose livelihoods have been damaged by this catastrophe, we must remember this is a engineering problem. Instead of having tons of federal agencies and congressional oversight committees berating each other and "wicked" oil companies, there should be a collaborative effort involving the Interior Dept., Energy Dept., petroleum companies, and sea grant universities to develop technologies to decrease the likelihood of offshore oil leaks and be able to reduce the damage from such leaks and the time required to stop these leaks when they occur. We also need to repeal idiotic depression era and sycophantically protectionist pro-union legislation like the Jones Act which keeps foreign vessels from delivering supplies between U.S. ports. We should also swallow our national pride and be willing to let experts from other countries such as the Netherlands, who have experience working with oil spills, to let them use their expertise when such accidents occur in U.S. waters or on land.
We need to develop rigorous scientifically sound standards and laws, regulations, and criminal penalties for conducting offshore oil drilling and violating safety standards written in succinct and plain English that leave no room for ambiguity. We don't need a biblical plague of lawsuits against BP and its contractors because that would prevent us from solving this technical problem and would financially damage, if not destroy BP, reduce the competitiveness of the petroleum industry and produce unnecessary price increases for consumers. Instead of saying "drill baby drill," we need to take a few deep breaths, learn some lessons, then "drill, carefully drill." We also need to abandon the idiotic notion that we can shake our dependence on foreign oil because we are to large and productive as a nation to support our petroleum needs with existing or even untapped domestic oil reserves. Apparently, the moronic Waxman doesn't want a pipeline to be built from the oil rich Canadian province of Alberta to the Gulf Coast because the tar sand oil is not "clean enough" for his snotty palate.
This spill is a tragic event, but it should not seduce us into believing that we can turn to solar, geothermal, wind, hydropower, or other energy sources as the magic bullet for our energy needs and for reducing environmental pollution. Let's roll up our sleeves, calm down, and start working on pragmatic and enduring responses so we can avoid a environmental tragedy like this occurring again.